Federal appeals court dismisses Florida primary challenge
ATLANTA (AP) - March 21, 2008 But the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in a ruling released
Friday, said the lawsuit "raises a number of interesting and
potentially significant questions," and gave the plaintiff an
opening to amend and refile the lawsuit.
The plaintiff, Victor DiMaio, a Democratic Party activist from
Tampa, Fla., said he would refile.
DiMaio filed the lawsuit in 2007 accusing the party of
disenfranchising Florida's Democratic voters by barring them from
having their say in choosing their party's nominee. The party
stripped both Florida and Michigan of their national convention
delegates because they moved their primaries to January dates that
were earlier than party rules allowed.
The Democratic National Committee argued the party has the right
to set its own rules and not seat delegates who refuse to follow
them.
The three-judge panel agreed with a U.S. district judge in Tampa
who dismissed the challenge, saying that DiMaio "undeniably"
lacked standing to bring the lawsuit because he had yet to vote in
the Florida primary when it was filed.
"Since DiMaio's complaint does not allege any actual or
imminent injury, nor suggest in any way how that 'injury' could be
redressed by a favorable judgment, we are without jurisdiction to
entertain the appeal," the ruling said.
But the ruling suggested he could file another challenge, now
that he has voted in the Jan. 29 contest.
The Democratic National Committee said it was pleased with the
decision.
"As two U.S. District Courts in Florida have found, and as the
Supreme Court has consistently recognized, national political
parties have a constitutionally protected right to manage and
conduct their own internal affairs, including the enforcement of
delegate selection rules," it said in a statement.
DiMaio told The Associated Press he was encouraged by the ruling
and would amend his lawsuit and return to court.
"This is a big victory," said DiMaio, who said he is neutral
in the presidential race. "As close as this election can be, these
little votes can make a big difference in who could be the next
president of the United States. That's why I'm anxious and ready to
go. And the clock is really ticking."
Florida and Michigan have had so far fruitless discussions about
possibly redoing their primaries. Any redo would have to be
completed by June 10 to be counted under Democratic National
Committee rules.
DiMaio's attorney, Michael Steinberg said he hopes the case is
decided before the party's national convention starts on Aug. 25 in
Denver.