Couple sues Google over map's street view
PITTSBURGH (AP) - April 4, 2008 Images of the home Aaron and Christine Boring bought in the
Pittsburgh suburb of Franklin Park in October 2006 appeared on
Google's "Street View" feature, which allows users to find
street-level photos by clicking on a map.
"A major component of their purchase decision was a desire for
privacy," according to their complaint, filed Wednesday in state
court, which also says the couple suffered mental distress.
The images must have been taken from the couple's long driveway,
which is labeled "Private Road," and that violated their privacy,
according to the complaint.
To gather photos for Street View, Mountain View, Calif.-based
Google sends vehicles with mounted digital cameras up and down the
streets of major metropolitan areas taking pictures. Many other
companies take real estate photos the same way.
Google spokesman Larry Yu said the site indicates that property
owners can get the company to removed images if they cite a good
reason and can prove they own the property depicted.
"We absolutely respect that people may not be comfortable with
some of the imagery on the site," Yu said. "We actually make it
pretty easy for people to submit a request to us to remove the
imagery."
If the Borings made such a request - especially if they told
Google its photos must have been shot from their driveway - Yu said
he is confident the image would be removed.
The couple's attorney, Dennis Moskal, said the point is that the
Borings' privacy was invaded when the Google vehicle allegedly
drove onto their property.
Removing the image won't undo that damage, nor will it deter the
company from doing the same thing in the future, Moskal said.
"Isn't litigation the only way to change a big business'
conduct with the public?" Moskal said. "What happened to their
accountability?"
Yu declined comment on the suit itself because the company was
still reviewing it.
Google is not the only Web site with a photo of the Borings'
property.
The Allegheny County real estate Web site has a photo, plus a
detailed description of the home and the couple's names. Similar
information, including pictures, of nearly every property in the
county is on the Web site.
Moskal said the county's image appeared to be taken from a
public street.
"The county's not trespassing," Moskal said.
Moskal said his clients did not wish to speak to the media. The
Associated Press could not find a listed phone number for them.
The Borings paid $163,000 for the property, according to the
county Web site. The county describes the home as a single-family,
four-room bungalow with a full basement. The one-story frame home
was built in 1916 and sits on a property that's a little less than
2 acres.
The home is 984 square feet with a fireplace and central heat
and county assessors graded it as being in "Fair" condition. The
county Web site does not mention the property's two detached
garages and swimming pool, which are visible in the Google pictures
and are mentioned in the couple's lawsuit.