It happened sometime Saturday night into Sunday morning.
Many of the cars were parked in the parking lot of AMG Motors service center on the 500 block of Fischer Boulevard. Others were parked on Oceanic and Beach View Drive.
One of the vehicles also had a Swastika symbol engraved on it.
The victims' estimate their loss at more than $4,000.
Police are attempting to get survellience video from nearby.
Anyone with information is urged to contact Toms River Police at 609-349-0150 ext 200.