Members of the Black Panthers are outraged over a question included in the paper's recent news quiz.
It asks readers where a three-year-old girl was murdered, offering a multiple-choice response.
The editor of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinal said the quiz is meant to review the week's biggest stories, but called that question a mistake and said he did apologize to the family.
The paper did issue a written statement in Tuesday's paper, apologizing for its insensitivity.
The Black Panthers say that's not enough, they want a full-page apology for what they call a mockery of the three-year-old girl's killing.