Yelda Sisman, 20, and Nilufer Cetin, 44, both of Pemberton, have been charged with 4th degree Theft.
Police said within hours of posting surveillance photos to their Facebook page, they were flooded with tips positively identifying the suspects.
- Police seek to identify remains of young girl found in Smyrna, Delaware
The theft happened on November 10 at the Church of Saint Isaac Jogues on Evesboro-Medford Road.
The stolen items included laundry detergent, winter coats and Kohl's gift cards.
In all, the items were worth $460, police said.
- Storm brings beach erosion, street flooding to Jersey Shore