Mom, son suspected in killing caught in NJ casino

ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. (AP) - October 16, 2010

Michelle Costello, 43, and her 19-year-old son, Peter, both of Las Vegas, were arrested at Resorts Atlantic City, state Police Sgt. Stephen Jones said. They were being held in the Atlantic County jail on a no-bail fugitive warrant pending extradition proceedings.

Jones said the patron, Jama Rhodes of Atlantic City, 34, approached casino security and told them there were "a couple of murderers on the casino floor." Rhodes could not remember the suspects' names, but told security officials that she had recently seen a media report about them that included their photos.

Rhodes happened to see the report a short time after the Costellos had gone to the business where Rhodes works, seeking to rent an apartment above the business, Jones said. She and a co-worker noticed that the Costellos resembled the people pictured in the report.

Rhodes then happened to be in the casino at the same time the Costellos were there and, upon recognizing them, notified casino security, who contacted state police detectives.

The detectives directed casino security to maintain surveillance on the pair while they quickly searched online for information about the suspects. They soon learned from the website of "America's Most Wanted" that the Costellos had been profiled on the show.

After confirming that the Costellos were wanted by Las Vegas police in connection with the Sept. 20 slaying of 65-year-old Bert English, state police detectives Thomas Wieczerak and Gene Hanemann and an Atlantic City police officer approached the Costellos and they were arrested without incident.

Jones did not know whether the Costellos had retained a lawyer. He also did not have further information on English's slaying.

According to the TV show's website, Las Vegas police found his body in the master bedroom of the couple's apartment after Michelle Costello called 911 to report that he was unresponsive. She and her son then left the area that day.

Costello and English had first married several years ago and eventually divorced, but they had remarried in July.

Copyright © 2020 WPVI-TV. All Rights Reserved.