Philadelphia Managing Director Brian Abernathy and city leaders are accusing Joel Freedman, the owner of Hahnemann, of trying to make money off the coronavirus pandemic, as the number of positive cases grew to 342 on Wednesday.
Freedman pushed back and said the amount he's asking for to rent the building is well below market price.
The hospital located at Broad and Vine streets in Center City has been closed since September.
The city and Freedman are now negotiating a six-month lease to use the building to help with coronavirus treatment.
As it stands now, Freedman is asking for more than $400,000 a month, but city leaders say that's unreasonable.
"I think he is looking at how to turn an asset that is earning no revenue into an asset that earns some revenue and isn't actually particularly thinking through what the impacts are on public health," Abernathy said.
Freedman fired back, claiming the price is eight times lower than the rental cost of a hospital in Los Angeles that's being used for coronavirus patients.
City officials accused Freedman of being "difficult."
"The space is necessary for us to continue to build out additional surge space and additional quarantine and isolation space and I'm cautiously optimistic that we'll find a path forward, but I hope that the owners will be more reasonable in future negotiations," said Abernathy
City council member Helen Gym believes the city should just take the building through eminent domain.
Eminent Domain was created for situations like #Hahnemann. This is a public health emergency and Philly is the largest city in the nation WITHOUT a public hospital.— Helen Gym (@HelenGymPHL) March 24, 2020
We cannot allow unconscionable greed to get in the way of saving lives. Eminent domain this property. https://t.co/OIlHFtkQrO
Gym tweeted Tuesday:
"Eminent Domain was created for situations like #Hahnemann. This is a public health emergency and Philly is the largest city in the nation without a public hospital. We can not allow unconscionable greed to get in the way of saving lives. Eminent domain this property."
Freedman said in a statement:
"Our team immediately responded to the City's interest in the Hahnemann and has been engaged in discussions with them for several days. Further, we have continually asked the City to make us an offer for the facility. We asked the City whether they desired to buy or lease the hospital, and after days of waiting for a reply, we took the initiative and submitted a term sheet. We offered to lease the facility to the city for six months or a year, whatever they think is necessary. We need the City to work with us for everyone to be successful," said Freedman. "I believe everyone has the right purpose at heart. The ball is in the City's court to tell us what it needs and is willing to do."
In a press conference Tuesday, Pennsylvania Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine said she thought reopening Hahnemann University Hospital would be "unlikely, given the state of the facility."
Levine said since Hahnemann has already been closed for six months, it would be "difficult to stand up such a facility."
Ultimately she said the decision on what to do regarding Hahnemann as a possible treatment site would be reached in conjunction with city leaders.