The borough says the images depict protesters striking McElree, including one screenshot that shows a protester swinging a phone at his head and another that shows a teen punching the plain-clothed chief.
Original video from the Feb. 20 protest also shows McElree placing a teenage girl in a headlock.
The confrontation occurred during an anti-ICE protest in Quakertown Borough, where dozens of students left class and marched through the streets. Five teenagers were arrested and held in custody for several days.
McElree had been on workers' compensation leave since the incident after borough officials said he was injured. In its first public statement about the altercation, the borough said:
"He was punched in the front of the head multiple times by a protester using a cell phone as an impact weapon. He was hit in the head by a protester swinging her backpack as a weapon."
RELATED: New recommendations after Bucks County Chiefs Association releases findings on Quakertown protest
Not all residents agree with that account.
"I saw a lot of videos, they weren't that," said Cindy Gibson of Quakertown. "They weren't anything until the police chief instigated this."
The Bucks County District Attorney's Office is conducting an independent investigation and has not yet released its findings. However, the borough said it "cannot wait any longer" to address the incident publicly.
A borough solicitor said McElree has returned to work and added that "the Borough is not taking any disciplinary action against Chief McElree or any QPD Officers concerning their actions prior to, during, or after this incident on February 20, 2026."
Some residents support that decision.
"I think it's great that he's back to work. He was only doing his job," said Tom of Ottsville.
Others continue to question the chief's actions and are waiting for the investigation to conclude.
"Why do you do that to a child?" asked Karla Arnold of Quakertown, who later said, "I don't think it's right. I don't think he should be back to work until all this is resolved."
In March, the district attorney's office dropped felony charges against the teens and removed them from house arrest. Attorneys representing the students have not responded to requests for comment on the borough's statement.
UPDATE (5/11/26): One of the protesters' attorneys, Donald Souders Jr., issued a statement Monday saying the borough's account is not a "full and complete account" of the events, nor is it a "balanced explanation of events."
The independent investigation remains ongoing.