Charges against 57-year-old Robin Massing of Audubon, New Jersey, for the Little League theft were announced last week.
Then, on Thursday, the Nether Providence Police Department announced arrested warrants for Massing and four other suspects.
According to police, the victim contacted police back in May to say $58,600 had been stolen from her TD Bank checking account.
The investigation showed that the suspects entered bank branches in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware to withdraw thousands of dollars at a time.
The additional suspects were identified as Shakeem Wilson, 32, and Mustafa Midgett, 29, both of Philadelphia; Kristina Oduaran, 26, of Newark, Delaware; and Brian Walden Jr., 35, of Sicklerville, New Jersey.
Nether Providence police also said that Massing has been identified as a suspect in numerous fraud investigations across multiple jurisdictions.