Christian Castro, 52, also faces state charges in the shooting.
"He must face justice in Minnesota," Minnesota AG Keith Ellison said.
Oswaldo Pirela, the minor league catching coordinator for the Padres, was detained by ICE at the El Paso International Airport early Sunday.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers may soon be outfitted with gloves that can deliver painful electric shocks intended to gain compliance from combative individuals.
The family is hopeful 65-year-old Iemad Saifo can be released on bond, so he can be home with family while the legal process plays out.