This time, it swallowed an excavator Friday night that was on site to make repairs.
Officials say they were able to remove the construction equipment, but it appears a second cave-in may have formed nearby.
It was around 1:30 p.m. Monday at James and East Kleinhans streets when the ground gave way while the driver of an SUV was passing by the area.
Video from a nearby home's Ring camera captured the moment the roadway collapsed.
A man inside the SUV was not hurt.
Beginning Jan. 6, crews plan to start replacing the existing cast iron water main that may have been responsible for the sinkhole.