Family billed $13,470 for half-hour of iPhone internet

SAN FRANCISCO -- When you travel overseas, you want to make sure you won't run up exorbitant fees on your smartphone.

A San Jose family thought they were protected from roaming and internet charges.

"It's like, 'Whoaaaa, what's going on?'" Vivian Chung of San Jose said, still reeling from the shock.

She and her children had just returned from an annual family reunion in Vietnam. Relatives from many countries gathered on an island off the southern coast, celebrated her mother's 84th birthday and frolicked on the white sand beaches. They returned home to San Jose brimming with good spirits until the jarring discovery sent them crashing down to earth.

"We know we cannot use the phone and it's always on airplane mode," Chung said. "How could this happen?"

It did happen. T-Mobile charged Chung $13,470 for internet access on her son Nicholas' iPhone. The charges all were incurred in a very short period while their flight was coming in over Vietnam. Chung estimates they racked up the charge in just one-half hour.

"How can this phone bill, like $13,740.19, in one half hour?" Chung said. "Oh my God, we almost fainted. I say this costs more than the trip."

Nicholas got in lots of trouble with his parents but insists he never used internet on his phone.

"I was confused and scared,'' Nicholas said. "Because $13,000 is a lot of money. I was like what? I didn't do anything."

Nicholas said he switched his phone into airplane mode for the entire trip just to avoid these kinds of charges.

"I know for a fact when you're on airplane mode you cannot have internet access,'' he said.

And that is true.

He does admit he was playing games on his phone during the flight -- but only offline games that do not need internet to play.

"I start a new game, you can see it doesn't require any internet at all,'' Nicholas said, demonstrating how he turned off his iPhone internet and still could play a mobile chess game -- the same one he was playing on the plane. It's the player against the software embedded in the app. It kept him busy for the entire flight without a data connection.

So, why the big charges?

"That's why we called T-Mobile right away,'' Chung said.

T-Mobile said Nicholas must have downloaded a movie or music or something. He didn't. But T-Mobile agreed to reduce the bill to about $3,800. Still, the family thought any charges were unfair.

"We didn't want to pay for something we didn't use,'' Chung said. "We didn't know where to go, but we watch Channel 7 news every night and I know about Michael (Finney). So we decided to call because we really needed your help."

She contacted our sister station, ABC7, which covers the Bay Area/San Francisco. ABC7's 7 On Your Side team contacted T-Mobile asking how the phone could rack up internet fees when it was on airplane mode. The company didn't provide an explanation except to say that Vietnam was not included in the T-Mobile free roaming plan, though it is now.

However, when ABC7 looked into the matter, they found that many mobile apps that don't require an internet connection still use data. Users may not even realize it, but the apps operate in the background, silently gobbling data for purposes such as updating software, refreshing social media, and sending ads.

Nicholas realized his chess game is one of those apps that run data in the background, which likely explains the huge bill.

However, after ABC7 contacted T-Mobile, the company agreed to cancel out the remaining charges on the bill, saying:

"Customers on T-Mobile ONE or Simple Choice North America plans have unlimited text and data - as well as low rate calling - in more than 210 countries and destinations around the world with Simple Global. However, T-Mobile recommends, before a trip, customers who are traveling internationally either call Customer Care, or check international roaming coverage and rates online."

Vivian was ecstatic.

"We were just like yes! Wow, 7 on Your Side!" she said. "I was so glad you are here to help all of us, a lot of people like me. And really, really thank you so much."

So, how can you stop apps from using data in the background? With an iPhone, go to settings, then look under Cellular Data, and switch the data use to the OFF position. It's similar for Android phones. Go to settings, find the app that may be using data in the background, and tap it to enable "restrict background data."

Here's how to fix your phone so you don't end up getting charged!

• For data information for Android phones, visit this page.


• For data information for iPhones, visit this page.