Judge allows Blackwater to open center
SAN DIEGO (AP) - June 4, 2008 District Judge Marilyn Huff ruled that the company would suffer
irreparable harm if it could not begin holding classes there for
Navy sailors.
Blackwater sued last month to force the city to issue final
occupancy permits after the required inspections were already
approved, claiming officials upended normal procedures because they
feared a political backlash.
The city responded that the company misled officials about the
nature of the center, which includes a multilevel mock ship built
out of cargo containers, to avoid triggering a full review by the
city planning commission and a possible City Council vote.
Huff found that other firing range operators in the city had not
been required to undergo similar reviews.
Classes for sailors will begin Thursday, according to Brian
Bonfiglio, a Blackwater executive overseeing the project. They were
originally set to begin at the center Monday but were suspended
pending the judge's ruling.
"I am officially ecstatic," Bonfiglio said.
The city said in a statement that it would probably appeal.
It said Blackwater's plan to use the warehouse for
"paramilitary training" makes it different from other firing
ranges. Sailors would move around the mock ship with firearms
instead of remaining stationary, as at an indoor firing range.
The company said the San Diego center would be used only to
provide contracted training for the Navy, not for training its own
overseas security workers.
"This is not a paramilitary outfit at all; it is a training
facility for American sailors, and the intent is to help them save
their lives and the lives of others and save their ships," said
Blackwater attorney Michael Neil.
Blackwater, the largest private security company in Iraq, has
been under scrutiny as a federal grand jury in Washington
investigates the company's involvement in the shooting deaths of 17
Iraqi civilians. The company is also under investigation for
possible weapons smuggling. Blackwater denies the allegations.
Blackwater applied for routine inspection permits as Raven
Development Group, a name its lawyers said the company had used for
other projects. Blackwater never explicitly sought permission to
convert a warehouse into a school, in part because it is in an
industrial area near the border already zoned for vocational
facilities.
Blackwater lawyers said in court May 30 that they had been
honest in their dealings with city inspection agencies. They argued
it was too late for the city to demand they go to the planning
commission because inspectors had already approved the required
permits.
Attorneys for Blackwater said the company risked losing part of
a $400 million Navy contract if it could not begin training sailors
in counterterrorist defense tactics by next week. The program is
part of a firearms training initiative started after the 2000
bombing of the USS Cole in a Yemeni port by terrorists in a small
boat.
The company has argued that elected officials moved to block the
project for political reasons ahead of the citywide primary
election held Tuesday.