Wife gets 11 years in NY `slavery' case
CENTRAL ISLIP, N.Y. (AP) - June 27, 2008 Mahender Sabhnani, 51, was expected to receive a lighter
punishment despite being convicted along with his wife Varsha last
December of a 12-count federal indictment that included forced
labor, conspiracy, involuntary servitude and harboring aliens.
Prosecutors contended Varsha Sabhnani was primarily responsible
for inflicting years of abuse on the poorly educated domestic
servants, which they referred to as a case of "modern day
slavery."
Her husband was charged with the same crimes, they said, because
he allowed the conduct to take place and benefited from the work
the women performed in his home; he operated a lucrative perfume
business from an office adjacent to the house.
On Thursday, as he sat weeping quietly with two of his children
at his side he watched his wife receive an 11-year sentence.
"Eye-opening, to say the least - that things like that go on in
our country," U.S. District Court Judge Arthur Spatt said of
testimony from the trial, which provided a glimpse into a growing
U.S. problem of domestic workers exploited in slave-like
conditions.
The victims testified that they were beaten with brooms and
umbrellas, slashed with knives, and forced to climb stairs and take
freezing showers for misdeeds that included sleeping late or
stealing food from trash bins because they were poorly fed.
Both women also were forced to sleep on mats in the kitchen. One
arrived in the Sabhnanis' Muttontown home in 2002; the second came
in 2005. Their passports and other travel documents were
immediately confiscated by the Sabhnanis, the women testified.
Prosecutors said the "punishment that escalated into a cruel
form of torture," ended in May 2007, when one of the women fled in
the early morning hours of Mother's Day. She wandered into a
Dunkin' Donuts wearing nothing but rags and employees called
police.
Federal sentencing guidelines had recommended a range of 12 to
15 years in prison for Varsha Sabhnani, who was identified as the
one who inflicted the abuse. In addition to prison, she will serve
three years probation and pay a $25,000 fine.
"In her arrogance, she treated Samirah and Enung as less than
people," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Demetri Jones.
Defense attorney Jeffrey Hoffman said 175 letters were submitted
to the court detailing Sabhnani's charitable acts around the world.
He called her "a woman who spent a lifetime doing good deeds" and
suggested some of the victims' testimony may have been exaggerated.
Hoffman said that around 2004 or 2005, Sabhnani's weight
plummeted from 325 pounds to 135. "She did it by starving
herself," and suggested a chemical imbalance and significant
malnourishment may have contributed to the way she treated her
servants. "She had become a very different person."
When his client was asked to speak, she trembled toward a podium
with her attorney and said, "I just want to say that I love my
children very much."
Her voice trailed away to a whisper as she added: "I was
brought to this earth to help people who are in need."
Spatt postponed a decision on the amount of back wages owed to
the women. Prosecutors suggested the women were due more than $1.1
million, while defense attorneys said the figure should be much
lower. The couple also face fines and are expected to forfeit their
home, which is valued at almost $2 million.