Philadelphia files appeal after judge rules Christopher Columbus statue can stay

A Philadelphia judge ruled on Tuesday that a Christopher Columbus statue could stay at at Marconi Plaza.

Friday, August 20, 2021
Judge rules Christopher Columbus statue can stay in South Philly
A judge has ruled that a controversial Christopher Columbus statue can stay in South Philadelphia.

PHILADELPHIA (WPVI) -- The City of Philadelphia says it's appealing a ruling that would allow a Christopher Columbus statue to stay in South Philadelphia.

Earlier this week, Judge Paula Patrick ruled that the controversial statue could stay at Marconi Plaza.

"It is baffling to this Court as to how the City of Philadelphia wants to remove the Statue without any legal basis. The City's entire argument and case is devoid of any legal foundation," said the judge in a seven-page decision on Tuesday.

The ruling overturns the decisions by the City of Philadelphia Board of License and Inspection Review and later the Philadelphia Historical Commission to remove the statute.

But on Thursday, the city filed an appeal on the judge's decision.

"We are very disappointed with the ruling and filed an appeal today. The statue remains in Marconi Plaza and will continue to be secured in its existing box," said a spokesperson with the city.

SEE ALSO: Suspect charged after photographer punched during protest at Marconi Plaza in South Philadelphia

A man is facing charges after another night of unrest near the Christopher Columbus statue at Marconi Plaza in South Philadelphia.

Rich Cedrone, president of the Friends of Marconi Plaza, fought to keep the Columbus statue at Marconi Plaza.

"We still don't believe it stands for anything against any other culture. That's not our message," said Cedrone.

The statue became a flashpoint in June 2020. Some in the city said Columbus and the statue is a symbol of hate and oppression. While others claimed the statue is an important part of Italian-American heritage and should be left alone.

Judge Paula Patrick wrote the city's primary justification for the removal was the civil unrest following the murder of George Floyd.

But in doing so, she wrote it was inconsistent with code, never showed to the court ongoing civil unrest beyond last June and failed to allow for 90 days of public input.

George Bochetto, the attorney for the Friends of Marconi Plaza, said, "I don't like a mob to show up and all of a sudden they start dictating what public policy is."

He says the city made a knee-jerk reaction.

"Everybody is entitled to a protest, but mobs don't rule, processes rule," said Bochetto.